Difference between revisions of "Kalmyk and Judeo-Tat/Lexical Selection"

From LING073
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 1: Line 1:
−
==jdt → xal==
+
=jdt → xal=
 +
==Solved Problems==
 
* (jdt) вокурде → (xal) тосхах (to build); неегдх (to open)
 
* (jdt) вокурде → (xal) тосхах (to build); неегдх (to open)
 
The generalization for this ambiguity depends on the object. If the object is a built structure, such as house or hut, it will translate to тосхах. TODO: complete explanation<br />
 
The generalization for this ambiguity depends on the object. If the object is a built structure, such as house or hut, it will translate to тосхах. TODO: complete explanation<br />
Line 14: Line 15:
  
 
==xal → jdt==
 
==xal → jdt==
−
* (xal) бәәх → (jdt) дуланмиш (live); поис (stand)
+
==Solved Problems==
−
This ambiguity is difficult to solve. In most (if not all) cases, бәәх as "live" seems to be used intransitively, which makes transitivity a difficult point for disambiguation. It is also difficult to make generalizations based on the adverbs that precede бәәх, since many adverbs can be used for both instances.
 
 
* (xal) зүркн (heart) → (jdt) гъирйет (courage);  дуьл (heart)
 
* (xal) зүркн (heart) → (jdt) гъирйет (courage);  дуьл (heart)
 
We chose the default translation to be дуьл (heart), since that was the most frequent usage among the examples we found. The default is overridden when it is followed by the verbs "need," "have," "want," "glow/shine."<br />
 
We chose the default translation to be дуьл (heart), since that was the most frequent usage among the examples we found. The default is overridden when it is followed by the verbs "need," "have," "want," "glow/shine."<br />
Line 22: Line 22:
 
**зүркн hундах (cause cardiac injury / emotional pain) - should be translated as дуьл
 
**зүркн hундах (cause cardiac injury / emotional pain) - should be translated as дуьл
 
**зүркн догдлад бәәнә (heart is beating) - should be translated as дуьл
 
**зүркн догдлад бәәнә (heart is beating) - should be translated as дуьл
 +
==Unsolved Problems==
 +
* (xal) бәәх → (jdt) дуланмиш (live); поис (stand)
 +
This ambiguity is difficult to solve. In most (if not all) cases, бәәх as "live" seems to be used intransitively, which makes transitivity a difficult point for disambiguation. It is also difficult to make generalizations based on the adverbs that precede бәәх, since many adverbs can be used for both instances.
 +
* (jdt) бирор → (xal) ах (older); дүү (younger) "brother"
 +
* (jdt) хэьер → (xal) эгч (older); дү күүкн (younger) "sister"
 +
These problems are impossible to solve; it requires much more knowledge of the context and personal information.
  
 
[[Category:Sp17_LexicalSelection]][[Category:Kalmyk]][[Category:Judeo-Tat]]
 
[[Category:Sp17_LexicalSelection]][[Category:Kalmyk]][[Category:Judeo-Tat]]

Revision as of 03:07, 30 March 2017

jdt → xal

Solved Problems

  • (jdt) вокурде → (xal) тосхах (to build); неегдх (to open)

The generalization for this ambiguity depends on the object. If the object is a built structure, such as house or hut, it will translate to тосхах. TODO: complete explanation

    • у ез хуьшге гийовьо ери хуьшде е куме вокурдедебу (He built a hut out of straw.) - should be translated as тосхах
    • тозе хунеьо едейе вокурде оморенуьт ьерчуьтам бисдо. (The new houses will be built no matter what) - should be translated as тосхах
    • киниге дере асдалай вокурд (someone slowly opened the door) - should be translated as неегдх
    • йедоне гъуш лэгӀэ вокурде жоьоб недо (No bird answered or open their mouths) - should be translated as неегдх
  • (jdt) муй → (xal) үсн (general; of human); килhсн (of animal, usually horse) "hair"

The generalization for this ambiguity depends on the subject. If the subject is a person, it will translate to үсн. If the subject is an animal, it will translate to килhсн.

    • муйдуразе геде (youth with long hair) - should be translated as үсн
    • муйьой ен артисткаш телуььой ен кемер жежурехуно тимтиж бируьт (The hair of the artists were upright like the pricks on a hedgehog's back) - should be translated as үсн
    • муйзарзарийе гусбенд (a sheep with curly hair) - should be translated as килhсн
    • муйзарзарийе кечи (a goat with curly hair) - should be translated as килhсн

xal → jdt

Solved Problems

  • (xal) зүркн (heart) → (jdt) гъирйет (courage); дуьл (heart)

We chose the default translation to be дуьл (heart), since that was the most frequent usage among the examples we found. The default is overridden when it is followed by the verbs "need," "have," "want," "glow/shine."

    • энүг күцәхин төлә зүркн кергтә (to do this, we need the courage) - should be translated as гъирйет
    • Хальмг Таңһчин зүркнд герлтҗ (The Kalmyk people’s courage glows) - should be translated as гъирйет
    • зүркн hундах (cause cardiac injury / emotional pain) - should be translated as дуьл
    • зүркн догдлад бәәнә (heart is beating) - should be translated as дуьл

Unsolved Problems

  • (xal) бәәх → (jdt) дуланмиш (live); поис (stand)

This ambiguity is difficult to solve. In most (if not all) cases, бәәх as "live" seems to be used intransitively, which makes transitivity a difficult point for disambiguation. It is also difficult to make generalizations based on the adverbs that precede бәәх, since many adverbs can be used for both instances.

  • (jdt) бирор → (xal) ах (older); дүү (younger) "brother"
  • (jdt) хэьер → (xal) эгч (older); дү күүкн (younger) "sister"

These problems are impossible to solve; it requires much more knowledge of the context and personal information.